there should autochange the "title of reply post" to (General)

by simon, Sunday, January 03, 2010, 14:55 (5243 days ago)
edited by simon, Sunday, January 03, 2010, 15:03

there should autochange the "title of reply post" to " my reply content is..."

that means below:

  • ...when you got lots of reply posts ,there got so many same title using your topic title; that's crazy noise
    ... it shoule be like that
  • hey all it's my topic title
  • reply: awesome title but i think ...
  • reply : hey all you think is but ...


I mean there need't be a "title input form " on reply form.
just catch some words of the first sentence of the reply to be a reply title instead of "reply:the topic title"

that will give a guest viewing whole thread some tips of what they are talking .

it's just a test reply that show what i'm meaning ...

by simon, Sunday, January 03, 2010, 15:05 (5243 days ago) @ simon

it's just a test reply that show what i'm meaning. the title of this post should being added by script self

Avatar

there should autochange the "title of reply post" to

by Micha ⌂, Sunday, January 03, 2010, 15:46 (5243 days ago) @ simon

Hi simon,

just catch some words of the first sentence of the reply to be a reply title instead of "reply:the topic title"

In my opinion, thats not a good idea because the first words are often "Hello", "Hi", "Good morning", ... followed by a username.

Your Example:

  • hey all it's my topic title (by Simon)
  • Hello Simon,...
  • Hi Simon,...
    • Hi Milo,...

regards Micha

--
applied-geodesy.org - OpenSource Least-Squares Adjustment Software for Geodetic Sciences

that is even better than this

by simon, Sunday, January 03, 2010, 16:28 (5243 days ago) @ Micha

,just as title says;-)

not in my opinion

by Auge, Monday, January 04, 2010, 00:09 (5242 days ago) @ simon

Hello

,just as title says;-)

I think, the title should tell us (the readers) something about the topic of the thread. With the eye on "thread drift" the user should be able to change the topic title.

In most cases the first few words of a posting don't fit these requirement(s).

Maybe it could be an option but I would't use it.

Tschö, Auge

RSS Feed of thread